---
title: "Trump Accounts: Separating the Art from the Artist"
date: 2026-11-20
tags: ["Political Thoughts"]
description: "These new accounts are incredibly progressive, and only a President like Trump could bring them into existence."
source: https://rossgarlick.com/writing/trump-accounts-separating-the-art-from-the-artist
---

<p class="standfirst">These new accounts are incredibly progressive, and only a President like Trump could bring them into existence.</p>

My wife and I have an ongoing bit in which we argue whether one can separate the art from the artist. I can appreciate Woody Allen’s movies, Picasso’s art, or Hemingway’s writing as standalone works, independent of how these men treated women (or worse); my wife tries to avoid the work of men who she thinks do not deserve a platform. We apply the same debate to Elon Musk: I root for Tesla and SpaceX even while finding Elon’s personal evolution nothing short of abhorrent (DOGE killing USAID was the straw that broke the camel’s back for me).

The more nuanced question is whether these men could have created their works *without* those personality traits, or whether you can get the good without the bad. That was already in my head when I heard [this *Invest Like the Best* podcast](https://colossus.com/series/invest-like-the-best/) with Brad Gerstner and Geoffrey Canada on Trump Accounts, the tax-advantaged investment accounts for American children created by 2025’s One Big Beautiful Bill Act.

They bear the name of an egocentric, highly corrupt Republican President who has engaged in some heinous acts in office (befriending Vladimir Putin, appointing three of the justices who overturned Roe v. Wade, mass deporting legitimate asylum seekers…). **But the Trump Accounts are a masterpiece: potentially the most progressive evolution of the social contract passed in my lifetime.**

They are small in scale to begin with: $1,000 for each baby born from 2025 through 2028, about $3.6bn a year. But they are effectively a redistribution of the means of production to the masses. This could never be achieved under a Democratic President or it would be accused of socialism.

<figure class="chart">
<figcaption><strong>Trump Accounts are small to begin with</strong>Annual cost to Washington. One square is $1 billion.</figcaption>
<picture>
<source media="(min-width: 600px)" srcset="/images/writing/trump-accounts-separating-the-art-from-the-artist/cost.png" width="1328" height="582">
<img src="/images/writing/trump-accounts-separating-the-art-from-the-artist/cost-mobile.png" width="960" height="948" loading="lazy" alt="Rows of squares, one per $1 billion a year: 1,600 for Social Security, 128 for the Child Tax Credit, 12 for Head Start and fewer than four, in green, for the Trump Accounts seed.">
</picture>
<p class="chart-source">Sources: Social Security Administration; Joint Committee on Taxation; FY2026 appropriations; CDC. The $1,000 seed covers babies born from 2025 through 2028.</p>
</figure>

## Inverting Piketty for the AI Age

In *Capital in the Twenty-First Century*, Thomas Piketty reduced rising inequality to a simple formula: r > g. When the rate of return on capital (r) exceeds economic growth (g), asset owners inevitably pull away from workers, because returns to capital compound faster than wages.

The advent of AI is proving Piketty correct. We are at the very beginning of the supercycle of token factories disrupting white- and blue-collar work, and labor’s share of US business output has already hit its lowest level since records began in 1947. I consider myself a techno-optimist, and AI will unlock gains for everyone (e.g. new cures for diseases), but it risks separating capital owners from laborers by an ever-growing canyon.

<figure class="chart">
<figcaption><strong>Capital compounds faster than the economy grows</strong>$100 invested at r = 5% a year, against $100 that grows with the economy at g = 1.5%.</figcaption>
<picture>
<source media="(min-width: 600px)" srcset="/images/writing/trump-accounts-separating-the-art-from-the-artist/r-g.png" width="1328" height="736">
<img src="/images/writing/trump-accounts-separating-the-art-from-the-artist/r-g-mobile.png" width="960" height="726" loading="lazy" alt="Line chart of Piketty’s r > g. $100 growing at 5% a year becomes $1,147 after 50 years; $100 growing at 1.5% becomes $211. The widening gap between the two lines is shaded.">
</picture>
<p class="chart-source">Illustrative, using Thomas Piketty’s long-run rates. The green line is where Trump Accounts put every child.</p>
</figure>

**Trump Accounts invert the equation, making *everyone* an owner of capital**, and may one day be seen as the source of Universal Basic Wealth. The New American Dream is not being a homeowner; it is being a stakeholder in the most productive assets in the most dynamic capital markets in the world.

[Asked in 1999 how to make $30 billion](https://buffett.cnbc.com/video/1999/05/03/afternoon-session---1999-berkshire-hathaway-annual-meeting.html), Warren Buffett replied: “Start young.” Compound interest, he explained, “behaves like a snowball of sticky snow. And the trick is to have a very long hill.” Eighteen years of untouched compounding, starting at birth, will be a powerful demonstration of that. The accounts also make large-scale philanthropy easy for the first time in history: the Dells have pledged $6.25bn, and in October Elon Musk pledged a SpaceX share to every kid in America.

## Upgrading the Social Contract for the 21st Century

Social Security was designed around an industrial-era bargain: trade your labor today for a collective safety net tomorrow. That promise relied on demographic assumptions—shorter lifespans and high birth rates—that no longer hold. Worse, it pits labor against capital and carries growing fiscal counterparty risk.

<figure class="chart">
<figcaption><strong>A promise built on a shrinking base</strong>Workers paying into Social Security for every person collecting it.</figcaption>
<picture>
<source media="(min-width: 600px)" srcset="/images/writing/trump-accounts-separating-the-art-from-the-artist/workers.png" width="1328" height="308">
<img src="/images/writing/trump-accounts-separating-the-art-from-the-artist/workers-mobile.png" width="960" height="396" loading="lazy" alt="Rows of circles showing workers per Social Security beneficiary: 5.1 in 1960, 2.6 in 2025 and a projected 2.3 in 2035.">
</picture>
<p class="chart-source">Source: Social Security Administration, 2026 Trustees Report.</p>
</figure>

Trump Accounts align citizens with capital, and the second-order consequences of this cannot be overstated. It may ultimately make the general populace more pro-capitalism as a rising tide raises all ships, while companies may also revise and broaden the scope of what fiduciary duty looks like into a much larger pact with society writ large. I believe the program, if invested in and expanded, may come to be lauded as the 21st century’s answer to a broader social contract in an era of capital acceleration, and a significant evolution in market-based capitalism.

I’m extrapolating, but the door has been opened and the infrastructure built, with 70mm accounts already in existence and 10,000 new accounts being created every day, automatically. Critics of new government programs often warn of a “slippery slope” where small policies inevitably expand. Here, that slope works in our favor. Once millions of families watch their kids’ accounts compound, no politician will dare let the program expire—and future Congresses will only make it bigger.

It is crazy to me that America hadn’t done this before, but maybe it took the right set of circumstances (and the right President): you can’t get the good without the bad.